By Kiran Patel
The latest Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report showed we still have a chance at keeping global warming levels below 1.5 degrees, but only with systemic, urgent change.
As buildings use about 40 percent of global energy and around 40 percent of the world’s natural resources, real estate needs to respond rapidly, and our window of opportunity to halve emissions by 2030 is closing. This need is set firmly against a backdrop of regulators, investors, occupiers and end clients demanding greater sustainability credentials for assets as part of the wider push towards corporate (and investing) net zero.
In what is a fast-changing regulatory environment, decarbonisation of existing buildings forms a critical part of governments’ net-zero strategies. In the United Kingdom, for instance, the government’s minimum energy efficiency standards consultation sets a target for a minimum EPC rating to a “B” by 1 April 2030 for all commercial rented property, with an interim milestone of EPC “C” by 2027.
Race against time
Research from Savills in 2021 concluded that 87 percent of the office stock in major UK office markets was rated EPC “C” or below. Industry estimates suggest that up to 80 percent of London’s office buildings do not meet an EPC “C” rating and will need to be upgraded by 2030 — given the tightening of requirements — to a “B” rating by then. This is equivalent to refurbishing around 15 million square feet (1.4 million square metres)every year in the UK capital. Furthermore, almost 10 percent of London’s office market is currently rated “F” or “G”, meaning that it will be illegal for this space to continue to be let.
Reflecting on these statistics, a significant volume of office stock — which is the biggest sector in the industry held by asset managers — will become obsolete in the short- and mid-term without investment to future-proof assets and improve EPC ratings to the minimum requirements. Common EPC improvement measures include building envelope improvements, such as roof, wall, floor and glazing insulation; installment of draught-proofing; and improving airtightness. Others include heating, ventilation and cooling improvements. These would require replacing old or inefficient boilers and air conditioning systems with high-efficiency alternatives with heat recovery systems, variable speed drives, improved temperature controls and programmable thermostats. Lighting upgrades are also necessary. Replacing traditional lights with LED or fluorescent lights, installing sensors and controls for dimming, occupancy controls, and daylight sensors are all vital upgrades. And installing renewable-energy systems, such as solar panels, if possible, is also expected.
Although the capital expenditure cost of carrying out such extensive work can appear daunting, not investing in property upgrades of this nature runs the risk of increasing obsolescence and being left with stranded assets with limited value.
The energy performance gap
EPCs are created through modelling, predicting the energy use rather than using measured energy use. The EPC calculations use standardised assumptions about occupancy, heating patterns and geographical location. This allows EPCs for the same building type to be compared. In other words, EPC provides an energy-efficiency rating for the property itself, rather than an in-use rating.
Statistics from Europe show that there is often a gap between predicted and actual energy use in buildings. This is known as the “performance gap”. An EU-funded project called Build2Perform, analysed more than 500nondomestic buildings in the United Kingdom and found that there was an average performance gap of 40 percent. Furthermore, a study by the Technical University of Munich in 2017 analysed data from nearly 900nondomestic buildings across Europe and found that on average, there was a 30 percent difference between predicted and actual energy use.
The performance gap can be influenced by factors such as occupant behaviour, maintenance and changes in building use over time. It is important to use EPC ratings as a benchmark, given their limited scope, but also to monitor actual energy use in buildings to assess the actual performance correctly. The goal to reduce carbon requires actual data collection with a pathway to net zero.
As concluded in the European DataWarehouse (EDW) EPCs across Europe analysis, common conversion factors are needed to make sure that an “A” rating in one country corresponds to a similar level of efficiency in the others. This will benefit stakeholders who work cross border, which is a “must” in today’s globalised world.
One way some countries are approaching the performance gap is through building in-use performance ratings. In Australia, in-use performance ratings have been used since 1998. NABERS stands for the National Australia Built Environment System and is an in-use energy, water, waste and indoor- environment rating system. The data must be from in-use building performance (not predicted, as with EPC data). NABERS ratings have reduced the Australian building performance gap by an average of 30 percent to 40 percent. Itis so successful that UK industry groups spent time looking at how to take NABERS and translate the rating for the United Kingdom. The result is that there is an office-specific NABERS UK rating system that is starting to be adopted in the United Kingdom.
Answering the challenge
The energy-performance gap between the designed performance of buildings and the actual performance in use, poses a challenge to asset and property managers to ensure that buildings are operating as efficiently as possible, given their specifications. The real estate fund management industry needs to actively take steps to answer this challenge by gathering and assessing monitored energy data for its assets under management, and also targeting unregulated energy improvement measures to complement the EPC rating and better inform business decision-making. Setting aspirational EPC targets, such as a minimum EPC “A” rating in the United Kingdom, or equivalent rating in the European context for new development and major refurbishment commercial projects, will reduce the risk of obsolescence. Enhancing occupiers’ engagement and encouraging tenants within leasing contracts to acquire green energy, provide consumption data and minimise the impact of the fit-out works will aid the pathway to net zero.
Looking ahead, there is likely to be extensive activity regarding EPC ratings as momentum around net zero gathers pace and core stakeholders gravitate towards best-in-class assets. This is not going to happen overnight, but all of us operating at the highest level of the real estate sector have to start in earnest now.
1. IMPORTANT INFORMATION
Savills Investment Management LLP is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the United Kingdom under Firm Reference Number 615368. Registered office is 33 Margaret Street, London W1G 0JD. Property is not a financial Instrument as defined by the Market in Financial Instrument Directive under European regulation; consequently, the direct investment into and management of property is not regulated by the FCA.
The following terms and conditions must be read before entering the website.
2. TERMS & CONDITIONS
The content contained within this website has been prepared for institutional investors only. Information contained within this website should not be forwarded to any other investor type.
The dissemination of the information contained on this website is only allowed in countries where Savills Investment Management LLP and its subsidiaries have notified or received permission from the local supervisory authorities. If no such notification has been received then no such permission has been granted, and the information contained here may not be regarded as an offer to purchase investment units.
Nothing on the following pages shall be regarded or taken as financial advice. Therefore, access to the following pages is on condition that it is to receive information only and does not constitute an offer to enter into any contract or agreement nor is it a solicitation to buy or sell investments. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance.
Please remember that past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. The value of an investment and the income from it can fall as well as rise as a result of market and currency fluctuations and investors may not get back the amount originally invested. Tax assumptions may change if the law changes, and independent advice should be sought. Property can be difficult to sell, and it may be difficult to realise your investment when you want to.
3. OTHER COUNTRIES
The information described within this website are not available in all countries, and nothing contained on this website constitutes an offer or solicitation to anyone in any jurisdiction where such an offer is not lawful or to anyone to whom it is unlawful to make such an offer or solicitation. By using this website you consent to the Terms and Conditions.
Whilst reasonable care is taken to ensure that information contained on this website is accurate, we cannot guarantee its accuracy and we reserve the right to change the information on this website (including these terms and conditions) at any time without notice. You must check these terms and conditions for changes each time you intend to use this website.
Savills Investment Management LLP provides this website on an "as is" basis and makes no representations or warranties of any kind with respect to this website or the content contained on it (including any text, graphics, advertisements, links or other item) and disclaims all such representations and warranties. In addition, neither we nor any other contributor to this website make any representation or gives any warranty, condition, undertaking or term either express or implied as to the condition, quality, performance, accuracy, suitability, fitness for purpose, completeness, or freedom from viruses of the content contained on this website or that such content will be accurate, up-to-date, uninterrupted or error free.
YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT YOU ARE SOLELY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE USE TO WHICH YOU PUT THIS WEBSITE AND ALL THE RESULTS AND INFORMATION YOU OBTAIN FROM IT AND THAT ALL WARRANTIES, CONDITIONS, UNDERTAKINGS, REPRESENTATIONS AND TERMS WHETHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, STATUTORY OR OTHERWISE ARE HEREBY EXCLUDED TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW. HOWEVER, NOTHING IN THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS IS INTENDED TO LIMIT ANY LIABILITY THAT SAVILLS INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT MAY HAVE UNDER APPLICABLE LAWS AND REGULATION.
Save in respect of liability for death or personal injury arising out of negligence or for fraudulent misrepresentation, we and all contributors to this website hereby disclaim to the fullest extent permitted by law all liability for any loss or damage including any consequential or indirect loss or damage incurred by you, whether arising in tort, contract or otherwise, and arising out of or in relation to or in connection with your access to or use of or inability to use this website.
The copyright on this website and its content belong to Savills Investment Management LLP. You may not make a permanent copy of or reproduce this website or any of its contents in any form. You may not reproduce or incorporate this website or any of its contents into any other website. You may only print or cache temporary copies of the content for your own personal non-commercial use. Savills Investment Management LLP welcomes links to this website from relevant third party websites. However, if requested in writing by Savills Investment Management LLP, links must be removed within 24 hours. Savills Investment Management and the Savills Investment Management logo are trademarks registered in the name of Savills Investment Management LLP in the UK and other parts of the world. Reproduction of these trademarks other than in order to view this website is prohibited. Nothing on this site should be construed as granting any licence or rights to use or distribute any site content without express written agreement.
7. INTERUPTIONS AND OMISSIONS IN THIS SERVICE
Whilst we take every care to ensure that the standard of this website remains high and to maintain the continuity of it, the internet is not always a stable medium and errors, omissions, interruptions of service and delays may occur at any time. As a result, we do not accept any ongoing obligation or responsibility to operate this website (or any particular part of it.
If any part of our terms and conditions is unenforceable (including any provision in which we exclude our liability to you) the enforceability of any other part of these conditions will not be affected.
This website may contain links to third party websites over which Savills Investment Management LLP has no control. Savills Investment Management LLP assumes no responsibility for the content of third-party websites or for any losses which may arise out of use of a third party website. The presence of a link to a third party does not necessarily mean that Savills Investment Management LLP endorses that site or has any association with the proprietor of that website.
10. GOVERNING LAW
The terms and conditions related to your use of this website are governed exclusively by English law except for the information provided by Savills Investment Management SGR S.p.A. which is governed by Italian law.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, as to these terms and conditions and your use of this website, the information provided by Savills Investment Management Asia Ltd (Japan branch) is governed by Japanese law. All disputes relevant to the use of this website shall be subject to the agreed exclusive jurisdiction of Tokyo District Court as court of first instance.
11. DATA PROTECTION